01.10.2022 0

Liberal Justices’ Ignorance is Cautionary Tale about Fake News and Identity Politics

Among the many threats our nation faces, this is among the most serious. The supposed intellectual giants of the Supreme Court are dangerously detached from reality, choosing to consume fake news and working in COVID isolation. We cannot trust these people to make judgements that affect our individual liberties and freedoms.

By Catherine Mortensen

A recent New York Post article notes that “the Supreme Court’s three liberal justices made a series of head-shaking comments” during last week’s oral arguments over two of President Joe Biden’s vax mandates which were so embarrassing even the corporate media fact-checker called them out. According to the Post, “the comments and claims made by the trio of Stephen Breyer, Elena Kagan, and Sonia Sotomayor were incorrect, ignorant, misinformed or hysterically exaggerated.

Justice Sotomayor, in particular, is a poster child of the threats posed by fake new and identity politics.

Justice Sotomayor became fodder for viral internet memes when she said, “We have over 100,000 children, which we’ve never had before, in serious conditionand many on ventilators.”

According to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) only about 3-thousand children are currently in the hospital because of COVID.

When Justice Stephen Breyer weighed in, he suggested the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) rule was needed because “hospitals are full almost to the point of maximum” and that “750 million new cases” had been reported in the US yesterday — despite the fact that the population of America is around 330 million.

In addition, information from HHSshows that nearly 21 percent of inpatient beds and more than 18 percent of ICU beds nationwide were unoccupied as of Friday.

According to the Post, Sotomayor, who did not join her eight colleagues on the bench for the arguments, but opted to take part remotely, at one point, claimed that implementing the requirement for businesses was necessary because “Omicron is as deadly as Delta … we have hospitals that are almost at full capacity with people severely ill on ventilators.”

Sotomayor’s statement contradicts experts who say Omicron is less severe than Delta.

Sotomayor said at another point in the argument that “I’m not sure I understand the distinction why the states would have the power” to institute a rule like the one being pursued by the Biden administration, “but the federal government wouldn’t.”

The Post noted that political consultnat Liz Mair on Twitter responded with, “Read the Commerce Clause and the 10th amendment lady.”

According to the Constitution, the amendment in question states that “powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”

Justice Kagan said that workers “have to get vaccinated so that you’re not transmitting the disease that can kill elderly Medicare patients, that can kill sick Medicaid patients. I mean, that seems like a pretty basic infection prevention measure.”

However, as we have seen time and again, even fully vaccinated individuals are capable of spreading COVID-19 to others.

Finally, Sotomayor asked why OSHA, which the Biden White House has charged with implementing the business rule, could not consider a person infected with COVID-19 to pose the same danger to colleagues as a machine emitting sparks.

Sotomayor was rightly mocked, again, on social media!  Michael Brendan Dougherty on National Review tweeted: “I love the idea that an Executive branch agency meant to protect worker’s rights is now adopting the argument that workers should be regulated like toxic chemicals.”

While this type of fake news is all over the internet and corporate news sites, it is shocking when it comes from Supreme Court Justices. It appears the three liberal members of the court are living in a world of fake news. And the fact that Justice Sotomayor refused to leave her chambers and be a part of the hearing, further compounds her isolation. She clearly is not getting her information from a variety of sources and people.

Among the many threats our nation faces, this is among the most serious. The supposed intellectual giants of the Supreme Court are dangerously detached from reality, choosing to consume fake news and working in COVID isolation. We cannot trust these people to make judgements that affect our individual liberties and freedoms.

Sotomayor didn’t even understand the difference between the powers of the states and those of the federal government. Every American student learns that in 9th grade civics, or at least they used to. Her ignorance calls into question why she is even on the court and how she was selected. Was she selected by President Barrack Obama based on her ethnicity and gender?

Friday’s hearing makes clear she was not selected for her keen intellect. And that is the danger of identity politics. It can result in political leaders who are not up to the job, as Sotomayor clearly is not.

Catherine Mortensen is Vice President of Communications at Americans for Limited Government.

 

Copyright © 2008-2022 Americans for Limited Government